TechF-16 versus SU-30: Expert analysis on the aerial power dynamics

F‑16 versus SU‑30: Expert analysis on the aerial power dynamics

Western F-16 fighters will soon appear over Ukraine, pitted against potential Russian adversaries like the Su-30SM aircraft. Is it possible to identify a clear favourite in this confrontation? Former Indian Air Force pilot Anil Chopra has shared his views.

Su-30 - illustrative photo
Su-30 - illustrative photo
Images source: © Getty Images | Mihail Siergiejevicz, SOPA Images
Norbert Garbarek

24 June 2024 19:07

This isn’t the first time experts have compared the capabilities of the F-16 with those of Russian aircraft. US aviator Jeffrey Fisher recently assessed American designs, comparing the F-16 with Russia's latest design, the Su-57.

The US pilot indicated that the F-16 has an advantage in this pairing. However, it is worth noting that the Russian fleet of Su-57s is limited. With only 10 units available, the F-16s will probably face other Russian fighters, primarily the Su-30SM and Su-35. Anil Chopra, a former military pilot from India, has assessed their effectiveness against the F-16.

He previously flew a Russian fighter and compares it to the F-16

Chopra notes that comparing the Su-30 to the F-16 is not entirely accurate. “It’s like comparing apples and oranges,” he explains. He points out that the performance of the Su-30SM should be compared with the F-15, while the F-16 is better matched against the MiG-29.

The difficulty in comparing the F-16 and the Su-30 arises from the latter’s larger size. This makes the Russian design easier to detect by radar and visually. According to Chopra, the Su-30 has an advantage over the F-16 in manoeuvrability at high attack angles and faster weapon targeting. “The Su-30 demonstrates greater agility and carries a larger payload,” he comments.

However, Chopra notes that the F-16 boasts a superior arsenal of missiles. “The American AIM-120 currently surpasses the Russian R-77 in range,” he stated, adding that American F-16s will likely be targeted by MiG-31 fighters equipped with six long-range missiles each.

The pilot identifies a key factor that will give an advantage

“Pilot skills will be the decisive factor in aerial encounters,” Chopra explains. He mentions that the F-16s sent to Ukraine will not have the “advanced radars and systems found in the Block 70/72 variants” but will still stand a chance against Russian aircraft.

According to the Indian pilot, the Ukrainians’ strategy should revolve around quickly closing in on the enemy, firing long-range missiles, and swiftly returning to base. Ultimately, Chopra opines that in most scenarios, Russian fighters could pose a significant threat to the Ukrainians.

Let us recall that the F-16s destined for the Ukrainian armed forces are designed for just under 33 feet long and have a wingspan of about 49 feet. The American fighter, which can reach approximately Mach 2 (about 1491 mph), can carry armament mounted on nine weapon stations.

For comparison, the Su-30, which Chopra does not consider a direct competitor to the F-16, measures nearly 72 feet long and has a wingspan of 48 feet. Additionally, it can carry armament on 12 stations.

© Daily Wrap
·

Downloading, reproduction, storage, or any other use of content available on this website—regardless of its nature and form of expression (in particular, but not limited to verbal, verbal-musical, musical, audiovisual, audio, textual, graphic, and the data and information contained therein, databases and the data contained therein) and its form (e.g., literary, journalistic, scientific, cartographic, computer programs, visual arts, photographic)—requires prior and explicit consent from Wirtualna Polska Media Spółka Akcyjna, headquartered in Warsaw, the owner of this website, regardless of the method of exploration and the technique used (manual or automated, including the use of machine learning or artificial intelligence programs). The above restriction does not apply solely to facilitate their search by internet search engines and uses within contractual relations or permitted use as specified by applicable law.Detailed information regarding this notice can be found  here.