Should you always turn off the lights? The myth-buster results revealed
When is it worth turning off the lights in a room? Some people believe you should always turn off the light when it's unnecessary. Others, however, think that in certain situations, it is more cost-effective to leave the light on. What is the truth?
10 June 2024 15:01
Rising electricity prices are affecting us more and more. In the search for saving methods, it's worth paying attention to lighting issues, especially since a long-circulating myth can be misleading. Gadgetomaniac journalist Karol Kołtowski checked whether you should always turn off the light when leaving a room and, if so, when it’s worth doing so.
As a rule, lighting should be turned off when not needed. During the day, it is worth maximizing the use of natural sunlight. However, it should be done wisely when using artificial lighting, turning off the light when unnecessary. A popular myth suggests that this isn't always worth doing.
For years, it has been believed that a short turn-off of the light is not cost-effective and that it is better to leave it on if you are leaving the room "for a moment." But how long is a moment? For some, it may be two minutes; for others—five, and still others, talk about fifteen minutes. This, however, is not true.
This topic was thoroughly investigated in the show "MythBusters". The results of the experiment are described on vanderbilt.edu. The researchers tested five types of lighting:
- traditional 90 W light bulb,
- 10 W compact fluorescent lamp,
- 70 W halogen,
- 1 W LED,
- 10 W fluorescent.
The critical element of the study was to check how much energy each light source uses during startup and compare this value with hourly energy consumption (the power of the device multiplied by an hour, expressed in watt-hours—Wh).
Is it worth turning off the light? Tests say it straightforwardly
The "MythBusters" experiment brought surprising results. It turned out that, in some cases, it is more cost-effective to turn off the light after less than a second. Here are the detailed results:
- traditional light bulb - 0.36 seconds,
- compact fluorescent lamp - 0.015 seconds,
- halogen - 0.51 seconds,
- LED - 1.28 seconds,
- fluorescent - 23.3 seconds.
Energy consumption is not everything, though. The bulb's durability is also essential, expressed not only in hours but also in switching cycles. It's important to remember that turning off the light for a few seconds can significantly shorten the bulb's lifespan, which might lead to additional costs associated with its earlier replacement.
From an energy perspective, it is worth turning off most types of lighting when leaving a room. The exception is classic fluorescent lamps, which must be on for more than 23 seconds before they consume as much energy as their startup requires.
In practice, however, it is recommended that you avoid turning off the light for a few seconds or several minutes. However, turning off the light can be cost-effective if you leave the room for a few minutes. This particularly applies to LED sources, which are durable and resistant to frequent switching on and off.